The short explanation
Both can be partly right. BMI only compares weight with height, so it cannot tell how much of your weight is fat or muscle. A body fat percentage looks more directly at fat, but the machines in gyms, which send a small current through the body, are not very accurate. Readings can change with hydration, meals, periods and even time of day. Many South Asian women have a normal BMI but a relatively high proportion of fat, sometimes called normal weight obesity, and this is linked with insulin resistance. A simple, reliable check is your waist size: for Indian women, a waist of 80 cm or more suggests more risky fat around the abdomen, even if BMI is normal.
What depends on your situation
The parts of this that change from woman to woman. Uncertainty is stated, not hidden.
- If your waist is high or you have other risks such as family history of diabetes, PCOS or high blood pressure, blood tests for sugar and cholesterol give a clearer picture than any machine.
- Strength training builds muscle and can lower body fat percentage even if weight does not change much.
- Use the gym machine only to track trends over time, measured under similar conditions, rather than as a single verdict.
What this answer cannot determine
The boundary of online education. These need a clinician who can see you.
- This cannot tell you your true body fat or health risk. Your waist size, blood tests and a clinician's view give a better picture.
Questions for your clinician
Take these with you. You can add any of them to an appointment card.
- Is my waist size in the healthy range?
- Should I test sugar and cholesterol?
- Is my body fat a concern given my family history?
- How should I track progress?
When to seek help
Clinician-approved guidance for this topic. When in doubt, being seen is never the wrong choice.
Book an appointment soon
- See a doctor within a few days if you notice strong thirst or frequent urination.
Raise it at a routine appointment
- Book a routine check-up if you want a fuller assessment of your risk.
Sources
The evidence this explanation is built on.
- Weight control MedlinePlus (US National Library of Medicine)
- Healthy diet World Health Organization
- Prediabetes MedlinePlus (US National Library of Medicine)
Who wrote and reviewed this
Every AskHer answer names its author. A clinically reviewed answer also names the clinician who signed it off — if no clinician is named below, it has not been clinically reviewed.
- Author
- AskHer Editorial (AI-assisted) AskHer's editorial team — not an individual clinician Works in English, தமிழ், हिन्दी
- Clinical reviewer
- Nobody yet No clinician has signed this answer off. That is what the “Editorially reviewed” badge means, and why it does not say “Clinically reviewed”. It was written and checked by AskHer’s editorial team against the sources listed above, and it is queued for a clinician who works in this area.
- Review status
- Editorially reviewed
- Last reviewed
- Last reviewed 11 November 2026
- Version
- 1
Correction history
Substantive changes are listed, not quietly edited away.
No corrections have been made since this answer was first published.
Did this answer your question?
Whatever you choose is filed against this version of the answer, never against you, and it is never shown as a count.
“Explain more simply” asks which part was hard to follow, so the author knows what to rewrite. “My question is different” tells the editorial team this answer missed your point, then lets you ask your own question privately. Nothing about you is sent with either.
Saving, following up and reporting are all private. Nothing you do on this page is visible to other readers or to the doctor who wrote it, unless you ask a question.

